| // Copyright 2013 The Go Authors. All rights reserved. |
| // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style |
| // license that can be found in the LICENSE file. |
| |
| // Package ssa/interp defines an interpreter for the SSA |
| // representation of Go programs. |
| // |
| // This interpreter is provided as an adjunct for testing the SSA |
| // construction algorithm. Its purpose is to provide a minimal |
| // metacircular implementation of the dynamic semantics of each SSA |
| // instruction. It is not, and will never be, a production-quality Go |
| // interpreter. |
| // |
| // The following is a partial list of Go features that are currently |
| // unsupported or incomplete in the interpreter. |
| // |
| // * Unsafe operations, including all uses of unsafe.Pointer, are |
| // impossible to support given the "boxed" value representation we |
| // have chosen. |
| // |
| // * The reflect package is only partially implemented. |
| // |
| // * The "testing" package is no longer supported because it |
| // depends on low-level details that change too often. |
| // |
| // * "sync/atomic" operations are not atomic due to the "boxed" value |
| // representation: it is not possible to read, modify and write an |
| // interface value atomically. As a consequence, Mutexes are currently |
| // broken. |
| // |
| // * recover is only partially implemented. Also, the interpreter |
| // makes no attempt to distinguish target panics from interpreter |
| // crashes. |
| // |
| // * the sizes of the int, uint and uintptr types in the target |
| // program are assumed to be the same as those of the interpreter |
| // itself. |
| // |
| // * all values occupy space, even those of types defined by the spec |
| // to have zero size, e.g. struct{}. This can cause asymptotic |
| // performance degradation. |
| // |
| // * os.Exit is implemented using panic, causing deferred functions to |
| // run. |
| package interp // import "golang.org/x/tools/go/ssa/interp" |
| |
| import ( |
| "fmt" |
| "go/token" |
| "go/types" |
| "os" |
| "reflect" |
| "runtime" |
| "sync/atomic" |
| |
| "golang.org/x/tools/go/ssa" |
| ) |
| |
| type continuation int |
| |
| const ( |
| kNext continuation = iota |
| kReturn |
| kJump |
| ) |
| |
| // Mode is a bitmask of options affecting the interpreter. |
| type Mode uint |
| |
| const ( |
| DisableRecover Mode = 1 << iota // Disable recover() in target programs; show interpreter crash instead. |
| EnableTracing // Print a trace of all instructions as they are interpreted. |
| ) |
| |
| type methodSet map[string]*ssa.Function |
| |
| // State shared between all interpreted goroutines. |
| type interpreter struct { |
| osArgs []value // the value of os.Args |
| prog *ssa.Program // the SSA program |
| globals map[*ssa.Global]*value // addresses of global variables (immutable) |
| mode Mode // interpreter options |
| reflectPackage *ssa.Package // the fake reflect package |
| errorMethods methodSet // the method set of reflect.error, which implements the error interface. |
| rtypeMethods methodSet // the method set of rtype, which implements the reflect.Type interface. |
| runtimeErrorString types.Type // the runtime.errorString type |
| sizes types.Sizes // the effective type-sizing function |
| goroutines int32 // atomically updated |
| } |
| |
| type deferred struct { |
| fn value |
| args []value |
| instr *ssa.Defer |
| tail *deferred |
| } |
| |
| type frame struct { |
| i *interpreter |
| caller *frame |
| fn *ssa.Function |
| block, prevBlock *ssa.BasicBlock |
| env map[ssa.Value]value // dynamic values of SSA variables |
| locals []value |
| defers *deferred |
| result value |
| panicking bool |
| panic interface{} |
| } |
| |
| func (fr *frame) get(key ssa.Value) value { |
| switch key := key.(type) { |
| case nil: |
| // Hack; simplifies handling of optional attributes |
| // such as ssa.Slice.{Low,High}. |
| return nil |
| case *ssa.Function, *ssa.Builtin: |
| return key |
| case *ssa.Const: |
| return constValue(key) |
| case *ssa.Global: |
| if r, ok := fr.i.globals[key]; ok { |
| return r |
| } |
| } |
| if r, ok := fr.env[key]; ok { |
| return r |
| } |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("get: no value for %T: %v", key, key.Name())) |
| } |
| |
| // runDefer runs a deferred call d. |
| // It always returns normally, but may set or clear fr.panic. |
| func (fr *frame) runDefer(d *deferred) { |
| if fr.i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "%s: invoking deferred function call\n", |
| fr.i.prog.Fset.Position(d.instr.Pos())) |
| } |
| var ok bool |
| defer func() { |
| if !ok { |
| // Deferred call created a new state of panic. |
| fr.panicking = true |
| fr.panic = recover() |
| } |
| }() |
| call(fr.i, fr, d.instr.Pos(), d.fn, d.args) |
| ok = true |
| } |
| |
| // runDefers executes fr's deferred function calls in LIFO order. |
| // |
| // On entry, fr.panicking indicates a state of panic; if |
| // true, fr.panic contains the panic value. |
| // |
| // On completion, if a deferred call started a panic, or if no |
| // deferred call recovered from a previous state of panic, then |
| // runDefers itself panics after the last deferred call has run. |
| // |
| // If there was no initial state of panic, or it was recovered from, |
| // runDefers returns normally. |
| func (fr *frame) runDefers() { |
| for d := fr.defers; d != nil; d = d.tail { |
| fr.runDefer(d) |
| } |
| fr.defers = nil |
| if fr.panicking { |
| panic(fr.panic) // new panic, or still panicking |
| } |
| } |
| |
| // lookupMethod returns the method set for type typ, which may be one |
| // of the interpreter's fake types. |
| func lookupMethod(i *interpreter, typ types.Type, meth *types.Func) *ssa.Function { |
| switch typ { |
| case rtypeType: |
| return i.rtypeMethods[meth.Id()] |
| case errorType: |
| return i.errorMethods[meth.Id()] |
| } |
| return i.prog.LookupMethod(typ, meth.Pkg(), meth.Name()) |
| } |
| |
| // visitInstr interprets a single ssa.Instruction within the activation |
| // record frame. It returns a continuation value indicating where to |
| // read the next instruction from. |
| func visitInstr(fr *frame, instr ssa.Instruction) continuation { |
| switch instr := instr.(type) { |
| case *ssa.DebugRef: |
| // no-op |
| |
| case *ssa.UnOp: |
| fr.env[instr] = unop(instr, fr.get(instr.X)) |
| |
| case *ssa.BinOp: |
| fr.env[instr] = binop(instr.Op, instr.X.Type(), fr.get(instr.X), fr.get(instr.Y)) |
| |
| case *ssa.Call: |
| fn, args := prepareCall(fr, &instr.Call) |
| fr.env[instr] = call(fr.i, fr, instr.Pos(), fn, args) |
| |
| case *ssa.ChangeInterface: |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.X) |
| |
| case *ssa.ChangeType: |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.X) // (can't fail) |
| |
| case *ssa.Convert: |
| fr.env[instr] = conv(instr.Type(), instr.X.Type(), fr.get(instr.X)) |
| |
| case *ssa.SliceToArrayPointer: |
| fr.env[instr] = sliceToArrayPointer(instr.Type(), instr.X.Type(), fr.get(instr.X)) |
| |
| case *ssa.MakeInterface: |
| fr.env[instr] = iface{t: instr.X.Type(), v: fr.get(instr.X)} |
| |
| case *ssa.Extract: |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.Tuple).(tuple)[instr.Index] |
| |
| case *ssa.Slice: |
| fr.env[instr] = slice(fr.get(instr.X), fr.get(instr.Low), fr.get(instr.High), fr.get(instr.Max)) |
| |
| case *ssa.Return: |
| switch len(instr.Results) { |
| case 0: |
| case 1: |
| fr.result = fr.get(instr.Results[0]) |
| default: |
| var res []value |
| for _, r := range instr.Results { |
| res = append(res, fr.get(r)) |
| } |
| fr.result = tuple(res) |
| } |
| fr.block = nil |
| return kReturn |
| |
| case *ssa.RunDefers: |
| fr.runDefers() |
| |
| case *ssa.Panic: |
| panic(targetPanic{fr.get(instr.X)}) |
| |
| case *ssa.Send: |
| fr.get(instr.Chan).(chan value) <- fr.get(instr.X) |
| |
| case *ssa.Store: |
| store(deref(instr.Addr.Type()), fr.get(instr.Addr).(*value), fr.get(instr.Val)) |
| |
| case *ssa.If: |
| succ := 1 |
| if fr.get(instr.Cond).(bool) { |
| succ = 0 |
| } |
| fr.prevBlock, fr.block = fr.block, fr.block.Succs[succ] |
| return kJump |
| |
| case *ssa.Jump: |
| fr.prevBlock, fr.block = fr.block, fr.block.Succs[0] |
| return kJump |
| |
| case *ssa.Defer: |
| fn, args := prepareCall(fr, &instr.Call) |
| fr.defers = &deferred{ |
| fn: fn, |
| args: args, |
| instr: instr, |
| tail: fr.defers, |
| } |
| |
| case *ssa.Go: |
| fn, args := prepareCall(fr, &instr.Call) |
| atomic.AddInt32(&fr.i.goroutines, 1) |
| go func() { |
| call(fr.i, nil, instr.Pos(), fn, args) |
| atomic.AddInt32(&fr.i.goroutines, -1) |
| }() |
| |
| case *ssa.MakeChan: |
| fr.env[instr] = make(chan value, asInt64(fr.get(instr.Size))) |
| |
| case *ssa.Alloc: |
| var addr *value |
| if instr.Heap { |
| // new |
| addr = new(value) |
| fr.env[instr] = addr |
| } else { |
| // local |
| addr = fr.env[instr].(*value) |
| } |
| *addr = zero(deref(instr.Type())) |
| |
| case *ssa.MakeSlice: |
| slice := make([]value, asInt64(fr.get(instr.Cap))) |
| tElt := instr.Type().Underlying().(*types.Slice).Elem() |
| for i := range slice { |
| slice[i] = zero(tElt) |
| } |
| fr.env[instr] = slice[:asInt64(fr.get(instr.Len))] |
| |
| case *ssa.MakeMap: |
| var reserve int64 |
| if instr.Reserve != nil { |
| reserve = asInt64(fr.get(instr.Reserve)) |
| } |
| if !fitsInt(reserve, fr.i.sizes) { |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("ssa.MakeMap.Reserve value %d does not fit in int", reserve)) |
| } |
| fr.env[instr] = makeMap(instr.Type().Underlying().(*types.Map).Key(), reserve) |
| |
| case *ssa.Range: |
| fr.env[instr] = rangeIter(fr.get(instr.X), instr.X.Type()) |
| |
| case *ssa.Next: |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.Iter).(iter).next() |
| |
| case *ssa.FieldAddr: |
| fr.env[instr] = &(*fr.get(instr.X).(*value)).(structure)[instr.Field] |
| |
| case *ssa.Field: |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.X).(structure)[instr.Field] |
| |
| case *ssa.IndexAddr: |
| x := fr.get(instr.X) |
| idx := fr.get(instr.Index) |
| switch x := x.(type) { |
| case []value: |
| fr.env[instr] = &x[asInt64(idx)] |
| case *value: // *array |
| fr.env[instr] = &(*x).(array)[asInt64(idx)] |
| default: |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("unexpected x type in IndexAddr: %T", x)) |
| } |
| |
| case *ssa.Index: |
| x := fr.get(instr.X) |
| idx := fr.get(instr.Index) |
| |
| switch x := x.(type) { |
| case array: |
| fr.env[instr] = x[asInt64(idx)] |
| case string: |
| fr.env[instr] = x[asInt64(idx)] |
| default: |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("unexpected x type in Index: %T", x)) |
| } |
| |
| case *ssa.Lookup: |
| fr.env[instr] = lookup(instr, fr.get(instr.X), fr.get(instr.Index)) |
| |
| case *ssa.MapUpdate: |
| m := fr.get(instr.Map) |
| key := fr.get(instr.Key) |
| v := fr.get(instr.Value) |
| switch m := m.(type) { |
| case map[value]value: |
| m[key] = v |
| case *hashmap: |
| m.insert(key.(hashable), v) |
| default: |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("illegal map type: %T", m)) |
| } |
| |
| case *ssa.TypeAssert: |
| fr.env[instr] = typeAssert(fr.i, instr, fr.get(instr.X).(iface)) |
| |
| case *ssa.MakeClosure: |
| var bindings []value |
| for _, binding := range instr.Bindings { |
| bindings = append(bindings, fr.get(binding)) |
| } |
| fr.env[instr] = &closure{instr.Fn.(*ssa.Function), bindings} |
| |
| case *ssa.Phi: |
| for i, pred := range instr.Block().Preds { |
| if fr.prevBlock == pred { |
| fr.env[instr] = fr.get(instr.Edges[i]) |
| break |
| } |
| } |
| |
| case *ssa.Select: |
| var cases []reflect.SelectCase |
| if !instr.Blocking { |
| cases = append(cases, reflect.SelectCase{ |
| Dir: reflect.SelectDefault, |
| }) |
| } |
| for _, state := range instr.States { |
| var dir reflect.SelectDir |
| if state.Dir == types.RecvOnly { |
| dir = reflect.SelectRecv |
| } else { |
| dir = reflect.SelectSend |
| } |
| var send reflect.Value |
| if state.Send != nil { |
| send = reflect.ValueOf(fr.get(state.Send)) |
| } |
| cases = append(cases, reflect.SelectCase{ |
| Dir: dir, |
| Chan: reflect.ValueOf(fr.get(state.Chan)), |
| Send: send, |
| }) |
| } |
| chosen, recv, recvOk := reflect.Select(cases) |
| if !instr.Blocking { |
| chosen-- // default case should have index -1. |
| } |
| r := tuple{chosen, recvOk} |
| for i, st := range instr.States { |
| if st.Dir == types.RecvOnly { |
| var v value |
| if i == chosen && recvOk { |
| // No need to copy since send makes an unaliased copy. |
| v = recv.Interface().(value) |
| } else { |
| v = zero(st.Chan.Type().Underlying().(*types.Chan).Elem()) |
| } |
| r = append(r, v) |
| } |
| } |
| fr.env[instr] = r |
| |
| default: |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("unexpected instruction: %T", instr)) |
| } |
| |
| // if val, ok := instr.(ssa.Value); ok { |
| // fmt.Println(toString(fr.env[val])) // debugging |
| // } |
| |
| return kNext |
| } |
| |
| // prepareCall determines the function value and argument values for a |
| // function call in a Call, Go or Defer instruction, performing |
| // interface method lookup if needed. |
| func prepareCall(fr *frame, call *ssa.CallCommon) (fn value, args []value) { |
| v := fr.get(call.Value) |
| if call.Method == nil { |
| // Function call. |
| fn = v |
| } else { |
| // Interface method invocation. |
| recv := v.(iface) |
| if recv.t == nil { |
| panic("method invoked on nil interface") |
| } |
| if f := lookupMethod(fr.i, recv.t, call.Method); f == nil { |
| // Unreachable in well-typed programs. |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("method set for dynamic type %v does not contain %s", recv.t, call.Method)) |
| } else { |
| fn = f |
| } |
| args = append(args, recv.v) |
| } |
| for _, arg := range call.Args { |
| args = append(args, fr.get(arg)) |
| } |
| return |
| } |
| |
| // call interprets a call to a function (function, builtin or closure) |
| // fn with arguments args, returning its result. |
| // callpos is the position of the callsite. |
| func call(i *interpreter, caller *frame, callpos token.Pos, fn value, args []value) value { |
| switch fn := fn.(type) { |
| case *ssa.Function: |
| if fn == nil { |
| panic("call of nil function") // nil of func type |
| } |
| return callSSA(i, caller, callpos, fn, args, nil) |
| case *closure: |
| return callSSA(i, caller, callpos, fn.Fn, args, fn.Env) |
| case *ssa.Builtin: |
| return callBuiltin(caller, callpos, fn, args) |
| } |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("cannot call %T", fn)) |
| } |
| |
| func loc(fset *token.FileSet, pos token.Pos) string { |
| if pos == token.NoPos { |
| return "" |
| } |
| return " at " + fset.Position(pos).String() |
| } |
| |
| // callSSA interprets a call to function fn with arguments args, |
| // and lexical environment env, returning its result. |
| // callpos is the position of the callsite. |
| func callSSA(i *interpreter, caller *frame, callpos token.Pos, fn *ssa.Function, args []value, env []value) value { |
| if i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| fset := fn.Prog.Fset |
| // TODO(adonovan): fix: loc() lies for external functions. |
| fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "Entering %s%s.\n", fn, loc(fset, fn.Pos())) |
| suffix := "" |
| if caller != nil { |
| suffix = ", resuming " + caller.fn.String() + loc(fset, callpos) |
| } |
| defer fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "Leaving %s%s.\n", fn, suffix) |
| } |
| fr := &frame{ |
| i: i, |
| caller: caller, // for panic/recover |
| fn: fn, |
| } |
| if fn.Parent() == nil { |
| name := fn.String() |
| if ext := externals[name]; ext != nil { |
| if i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "\t(external)") |
| } |
| return ext(fr, args) |
| } |
| if fn.Blocks == nil { |
| panic("no code for function: " + name) |
| } |
| } |
| |
| // generic function body? |
| if fn.TypeParams().Len() > 0 && len(fn.TypeArgs()) == 0 { |
| panic("interp requires ssa.BuilderMode to include InstantiateGenerics to execute generics") |
| } |
| |
| fr.env = make(map[ssa.Value]value) |
| fr.block = fn.Blocks[0] |
| fr.locals = make([]value, len(fn.Locals)) |
| for i, l := range fn.Locals { |
| fr.locals[i] = zero(deref(l.Type())) |
| fr.env[l] = &fr.locals[i] |
| } |
| for i, p := range fn.Params { |
| fr.env[p] = args[i] |
| } |
| for i, fv := range fn.FreeVars { |
| fr.env[fv] = env[i] |
| } |
| for fr.block != nil { |
| runFrame(fr) |
| } |
| // Destroy the locals to avoid accidental use after return. |
| for i := range fn.Locals { |
| fr.locals[i] = bad{} |
| } |
| return fr.result |
| } |
| |
| // runFrame executes SSA instructions starting at fr.block and |
| // continuing until a return, a panic, or a recovered panic. |
| // |
| // After a panic, runFrame panics. |
| // |
| // After a normal return, fr.result contains the result of the call |
| // and fr.block is nil. |
| // |
| // A recovered panic in a function without named return parameters |
| // (NRPs) becomes a normal return of the zero value of the function's |
| // result type. |
| // |
| // After a recovered panic in a function with NRPs, fr.result is |
| // undefined and fr.block contains the block at which to resume |
| // control. |
| func runFrame(fr *frame) { |
| defer func() { |
| if fr.block == nil { |
| return // normal return |
| } |
| if fr.i.mode&DisableRecover != 0 { |
| return // let interpreter crash |
| } |
| fr.panicking = true |
| fr.panic = recover() |
| if fr.i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "Panicking: %T %v.\n", fr.panic, fr.panic) |
| } |
| fr.runDefers() |
| fr.block = fr.fn.Recover |
| }() |
| |
| for { |
| if fr.i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, ".%s:\n", fr.block) |
| } |
| block: |
| for _, instr := range fr.block.Instrs { |
| if fr.i.mode&EnableTracing != 0 { |
| if v, ok := instr.(ssa.Value); ok { |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "\t", v.Name(), "=", instr) |
| } else { |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "\t", instr) |
| } |
| } |
| switch visitInstr(fr, instr) { |
| case kReturn: |
| return |
| case kNext: |
| // no-op |
| case kJump: |
| break block |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| |
| // doRecover implements the recover() built-in. |
| func doRecover(caller *frame) value { |
| // recover() must be exactly one level beneath the deferred |
| // function (two levels beneath the panicking function) to |
| // have any effect. Thus we ignore both "defer recover()" and |
| // "defer f() -> g() -> recover()". |
| if caller.i.mode&DisableRecover == 0 && |
| caller != nil && !caller.panicking && |
| caller.caller != nil && caller.caller.panicking { |
| caller.caller.panicking = false |
| p := caller.caller.panic |
| caller.caller.panic = nil |
| |
| // TODO(adonovan): support runtime.Goexit. |
| switch p := p.(type) { |
| case targetPanic: |
| // The target program explicitly called panic(). |
| return p.v |
| case runtime.Error: |
| // The interpreter encountered a runtime error. |
| return iface{caller.i.runtimeErrorString, p.Error()} |
| case string: |
| // The interpreter explicitly called panic(). |
| return iface{caller.i.runtimeErrorString, p} |
| default: |
| panic(fmt.Sprintf("unexpected panic type %T in target call to recover()", p)) |
| } |
| } |
| return iface{} |
| } |
| |
| // Interpret interprets the Go program whose main package is mainpkg. |
| // mode specifies various interpreter options. filename and args are |
| // the initial values of os.Args for the target program. sizes is the |
| // effective type-sizing function for this program. |
| // |
| // Interpret returns the exit code of the program: 2 for panic (like |
| // gc does), or the argument to os.Exit for normal termination. |
| // |
| // The SSA program must include the "runtime" package. |
| // |
| // Type parameterized functions must have been built with |
| // InstantiateGenerics in the ssa.BuilderMode to be interpreted. |
| func Interpret(mainpkg *ssa.Package, mode Mode, sizes types.Sizes, filename string, args []string) (exitCode int) { |
| i := &interpreter{ |
| prog: mainpkg.Prog, |
| globals: make(map[*ssa.Global]*value), |
| mode: mode, |
| sizes: sizes, |
| goroutines: 1, |
| } |
| runtimePkg := i.prog.ImportedPackage("runtime") |
| if runtimePkg == nil { |
| panic("ssa.Program doesn't include runtime package") |
| } |
| i.runtimeErrorString = runtimePkg.Type("errorString").Object().Type() |
| |
| initReflect(i) |
| |
| i.osArgs = append(i.osArgs, filename) |
| for _, arg := range args { |
| i.osArgs = append(i.osArgs, arg) |
| } |
| |
| for _, pkg := range i.prog.AllPackages() { |
| // Initialize global storage. |
| for _, m := range pkg.Members { |
| switch v := m.(type) { |
| case *ssa.Global: |
| cell := zero(deref(v.Type())) |
| i.globals[v] = &cell |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| |
| // Top-level error handler. |
| exitCode = 2 |
| defer func() { |
| if exitCode != 2 || i.mode&DisableRecover != 0 { |
| return |
| } |
| switch p := recover().(type) { |
| case exitPanic: |
| exitCode = int(p) |
| return |
| case targetPanic: |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "panic:", toString(p.v)) |
| case runtime.Error: |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "panic:", p.Error()) |
| case string: |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "panic:", p) |
| default: |
| fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "panic: unexpected type: %T: %v\n", p, p) |
| } |
| |
| // TODO(adonovan): dump panicking interpreter goroutine? |
| // buf := make([]byte, 0x10000) |
| // runtime.Stack(buf, false) |
| // fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, string(buf)) |
| // (Or dump panicking target goroutine?) |
| }() |
| |
| // Run! |
| call(i, nil, token.NoPos, mainpkg.Func("init"), nil) |
| if mainFn := mainpkg.Func("main"); mainFn != nil { |
| call(i, nil, token.NoPos, mainFn, nil) |
| exitCode = 0 |
| } else { |
| fmt.Fprintln(os.Stderr, "No main function.") |
| exitCode = 1 |
| } |
| return |
| } |
| |
| // deref returns a pointer's element type; otherwise it returns typ. |
| // TODO(adonovan): Import from ssa? |
| func deref(typ types.Type) types.Type { |
| if p, ok := typ.Underlying().(*types.Pointer); ok { |
| return p.Elem() |
| } |
| return typ |
| } |