| # Smaller Go 1.7 binaries |
| 18 Aug 2016 |
| Summary: Go 1.7 includes some binary size reductions important for small devices. |
| |
| David Crawshaw |
| crawshaw@golang.org |
| |
| ## Introduction |
| |
| Go was designed for writing servers. |
| That is how it is most widely used today, and as a result a lot of |
| work on the runtime and compiler is focused on issues that matter to |
| servers: latency, ease of deployment, precise garbage collection, |
| fast startup time, performance. |
| |
| As Go gets used for a wider variety of programs, there are new issues that must be considered. |
| One of these is binary size. |
| It has been on the radar for a long time |
| (issue [\#6853](https://golang.org/issue/6853) was filed over two |
| years ago), but the growing interest in using Go for |
| deploying binaries on smaller devices — such as the Raspberry Pi or |
| mobile devices — means it received some attention for the Go 1.7 |
| release. |
| |
| ## Work done in Go 1.7 |
| |
| Three significant changes in Go 1.7 affect binary size. |
| |
| The first is the new SSA backend that was enabled for AMD64 in this release. |
| While the primary motivation for SSA was improved performance, the |
| better generated code is also smaller. |
| The SSA backend shrinks Go binaries by ~5%. |
| We expect larger gains for the more RISC-like architectures |
| like ARM and MIPS when those backends have been converted to SSA in Go 1.8. |
| |
| The second change is method pruning. |
| Until 1.6, all methods on all used types were kept, even if some of |
| the methods were never called. |
| This is because they might be called through an interface, or called |
| dynamically using the reflect package. |
| Now the compiler discards any unexported methods that do not match an |
| interface. |
| Similarly the linker can discard other exported methods, those that are only |
| accessible through reflection, if the corresponding |
| [reflection features](https://golang.org/pkg/reflect/#Value.Call) |
| are not used anywhere in the program. |
| That change shrinks binaries by 5–20%. |
| |
| The third change is a more compact format for run-time type |
| information used by the reflect package. |
| The encoding format was originally designed to make the decoder in |
| the runtime and reflect packages as simple as possible. By making this |
| code a bit harder to read we can compress the format without affecting |
| the run-time performance of Go programs. |
| The new format shrinks Go binaries by a further 5–15%. |
| Libraries built for Android and archives built for iOS shrink further |
| as the new format contains fewer pointers, each of which requires |
| dynamic relocations in position independent code. |
| |
| In addition, there were many small improvements such as improved |
| interface data layout, better static data layout, and simplified |
| dependencies. For example, the HTTP client no longer links in the entire HTTP |
| server. |
| The full list of changes can be found in issue |
| [\#6853](https://golang.org/issue/6853). |
| |
| ## Results |
| |
| Typical programs, ranging from tiny toys to large production programs, |
| are about 30% smaller when built with Go 1.7. |
| |
| The canonical hello world program goes from 2.3MB to 1.6MB: |
| |
| package main |
| |
| import "fmt" |
| |
| func main() { |
| fmt.Println("Hello, World!") |
| } |
| |
| When compiled without debugging information the statically |
| linked binary is now under a megabyte. |
| |
| .image go1.7-binary-size.png |
| |
| A large production program used for testing this cycle, `jujud`, went from 94MB |
| to 67MB. |
| |
| Position-independent binaries are 50% smaller. |
| |
| In a position-independent executable (PIE), a pointer in a read-only |
| data section requires a dynamic relocation. |
| Because the new format for type information replaces pointers by |
| section offsets, it saves 28 bytes per pointer. |
| |
| Position-independent executables with debugging information removed |
| are particularly important to mobile developers, as this is the kind |
| of program shipped to phones. |
| Big downloads make for a poor user experience, so the reduction here |
| is good news. |
| |
| ## Future Work |
| |
| Several changes to the run-time type information were too late for the |
| Go 1.7 freeze, but will hopefully make it into 1.8, further shrinking |
| programs, especially position-independent ones. |
| |
| These changes are all conservative, reducing binary size without increasing |
| build time, startup time, overall execution time, or memory usage. |
| We could take more radical steps to reduce binary size: the |
| [upx](http://upx.sourceforge.net/) tool for compressing executables |
| shrinks binaries by another 50% at the cost of increased startup time |
| and potentially increased memory use. |
| For extremely small systems (the kind that might live on a keychain) |
| we could build a version of Go without reflection, though it is |
| unclear whether such a restricted language would be sufficiently |
| useful. |
| For some algorithms in the runtime we could use slower but more |
| compact implementions when every kilobyte counts. |
| All of these call for more research in later development cycles. |
| |
| To the many contributors who helped make Go 1.7 binaries smaller, |
| thank you! |